Every broker knows the feeling of opening the PI renewal. The premium’s up again. The excess is up again, and the questions run longer than they did last year. If you’re an authorised representative, your licensee carries the policy and the compensation obligation behind it, but your files, your conduct, and your controls still shape how the underwriter reads the risk sitting behind your book.
The underwriter doesn’t sit inside your brokerage. They don’t see the file notes you keep, how you handle a complaint, or the process you run at renewal. The submission is the only window they get, and most brokerages hand over a completed form without ever building the evidence behind it.
You can’t control every allegation a client makes or where the market moves next. What you can control is whether the underwriter receives an accurate, coherent, and evidenced account of the risk you actually are.
What the questions are really testing
Chubb’s own standard PI proposal form asks about revenue and premium split, staff numbers, and whether anyone connected to the business has faced a claim, an inquiry, or disciplinary action in the past five years. For a brokerage, the same categories extend further: how your authorised representatives are supervised, who holds binder or claims authority, and what your prior insurer’s terms, limits, and excess actually were.
None of these questions are really asking what happened in isolation. They’re asking how reliably your business prevents problems, catches them early, escalates them properly, and learns from them afterward. A clean answer with no supporting detail behind it doesn’t read as low risk. It reads as unexamined.
Build the evidence pack
Start gathering this well before the form arrives:
- Current business structure, trading names, and any recent acquisitions or mergers.
- Accurate revenue and premium-placement figures, with an explanation for anything that moved sharply.
- Staff and AR numbers, their qualifications, supervision arrangements, and recent training.
- Your current risk-management and compliance procedures, as they’re actually followed, not as they were written three years ago.
- Your latest audit report, what it found, and evidence the fixes were completed.
- Complaints, breaches, incidents, and notifications, reconciled against each other rather than sitting in separate systems.
- Details of any claims or circumstances, including present status and what’s been done about them.
- Anything likely to prompt a follow-up question, with the explanation attached before it’s asked for.
Once you’ve gathered it, organise it into a short covering document rather than leaving the underwriter to piece it together from the form alone: what the brokerage does, who runs it and how they’re supervised, the controls in place, the claims and complaints experience, what changed as a result, and the cover you’re actually asking for and why.
Handle adverse history honestly
Don’t minimise, relabel, or leave out a complaint or a control failure to make the form look cleaner. Check across directors, principals, staff, and the relevant records before answering any claims-and-circumstances question, then give the underwriter what actually happened, its status, the root cause, and the corrective action you’ve completed.
A standard PI proposal asks this under a duty of disclosure, and warns that non-disclosure can reduce what the insurer pays, lead to cancellation, or, where it’s fraudulent, let the insurer treat the policy as if it never existed. Treat your answers as a formal representation, not marketing copy.
A difficult fact with a credible remediation story is more useful to an underwriter than a vague answer that raises another question. None of this guarantees a better price. It gives the underwriter a complete basis to assess the risk you actually are.
Don’t wait for renewal
PI cover is usually written on a claims-made basis, so timing matters more than most brokers treat it. Don’t hold a potential circumstance until the renewal form is due. Australian insurance law actually protects you for doing the opposite: notify your insurer in writing of a fact that might give rise to a claim before your cover expires, and they can’t refuse a later claim purely because it was eventually made after that expiry.
Check your new policy’s retroactive date too, not only its premium. A retroactive date can exclude claims arising from work done before it, so continuity matters as much as price.
This is general information, not advice on your specific policy. Run any notification decision past your actual wording and your licensee or compliance adviser first.
Look past the premium
A cheaper premium isn’t the only thing worth reviewing at renewal. Check whether every entity and AR arrangement is actually covered, whether the indemnity limit and any aggregate still suit your exposure, whether the excess is one you could actually absorb, how defence costs are treated, and what exclusions or sublimits apply to what your brokerage actually does now. Growth in revenue, clients, or representatives changes what’s adequate, so the assessment needs revisiting every year, not just the number.
The strongest submission is built all year
The strongest PI renewal work happens long before the form arrives: clear files, consistent procedures, audits that get followed up, and problems that get escalated and closed out rather than left open. Renewal simply makes that work visible, or exposes that it wasn’t happening.
That’s the shape of Better Broker’s compliance support for the brokers in its network: regular audits designed to catch gaps early, guidance on documentation and policy wording, and underwriting experience brokers can draw on to understand what an underwriter is actually trying to assess. It sits alongside the broader argument that compliance is core to long-term broker success, not a box to tick once a year.
Could your brokerage show an underwriter exactly how it manages advice, complaints, and control? If the answer isn’t obvious, get in touch and talk through what a stronger submission looks like for your book.