A Federal Court Ruling on “We Compare the Market” Should Make Every Broker Check Their Own Website

A Federal Court Ruling on We Compare the Market Should Make Every Broker Check Their Own Website

Your website says you compare the market. A client asks what that actually means: how many insurers, which ones, how you picked them. It’s a fair question, and after 8 September 2026, it’s also a legal one.

The Federal Court found that Choosi, one of Australia’s best known insurance comparison brands, misled consumers for years about how many insurers it actually compared. Despite marketing that promised access to a range of insurers, every funeral insurance policy Choosi sold from July 2019 came from a single insurer, Hannover Life Re of Australasia, and life insurance followed a similar pattern. Justice Anderson ruled that a reasonable consumer would understand “range” to mean more than two insurers, so the claim was false regardless of what Choosi itself thought the word meant. Choosi’s ads had run more than 300,000 times to a cumulative audience above a billion, and ASIC says the business earned over $61 million in commissions on more than 13,000 policies sold that way.

Ten days later, ASIC filed a separate case against Clark Family Pty Ltd, alleging the company ran up to 70 websites promising genuine, tailored insurance and loan comparisons, then auctioned consumer details to whichever broker bid highest for the lead. Those allegations haven’t been tested in court, but they sit alongside the Choosi finding as part of the same regulatory focus: whether what a comparison or lead service claims to offer actually matches what it does.

Neither business is an insurance broker, but the language in the judgment is language brokers use every day. “We compare the market.” “Access to all leading insurers.” “Tailored recommendations.” “Independent comparison.” Justice Anderson’s reasoning didn’t turn on whether those words were technically defensible. It turned on what a reasonable consumer would understand them to mean, and that same test applies to anyone using them, broker or not.

A few things are worth checking against your own website and terms of engagement. Does “we compare the market” match how many insurers you actually approach for a given class, or is it closer to your usual two or three? If you buy leads, do you know what the lead generator told that consumer before you received the enquiry, and whether they already believed they’d been given a comparison? Can you show, if asked, why you approached the markets you did and not others? And is “best” anywhere in your marketing something you can actually support, or is it doing more work than your process backs up?

Making the market-selection story one you can prove

None of this means a smaller or more targeted panel is a problem. A brokerage that works with three or four insurers for a class because those are the right markets for that risk isn’t what the Federal Court was pointing at. The issue is claiming broader coverage than the panel actually represents. Compliance support inside Better Broker reviews website and advertising language against what a brokerage can actually evidence, and helps document which markets were approached and why for a given placement, so the record exists before a complaint or regulatory enquiry ever does. Placement support does the other half of the job, building a genuine, well-reasoned market search that doesn’t need to overstate itself to be worth telling a client about.

More on how the network supports compliance and placement practice.